Friday, 31 May 2013

Is God a Creator Or a Consciousness?

For from him and through him and to him are all things. To him be the glory forever! Amen. -Romans 11: 36 

In my childhood days I used to ask people about the existence of God. One of my friends introduced me to Advaita, a popular Hindu belief or philosophy that would help a person to know God in a better way. Advaita means non-dual or "not two." This oneness is a fundamental quality of everything. Everything is a part of and made of one non-dual consciousness. Often the question arises, "If it is all one thing, why don’t I experience it that way?" This is confusing oneness for the appearance of sameness. Things can appear different without being separate. Just look at your hand for a moment. Your fingers are all different from each other, but are they separate? They all arise from the same hand. Similarly, the objects, animals, plants and people in the world are all definitely different in their appearance and functioning. But they are all connected at their source—they come from the same source.

This one Being that is behind all life has an infinite number of different expressions that we experience as different objects. To continue with the hand analogy, your fingers are all made of the same substance. They are made up of similar tissues, cells, atoms, and at the deepest level, subatomic particles. Similarly, when your experience of reality becomes more subtle, you discover that everything is just different expressions of one field of non dual Being. Most people who believe in Advaita use the expressions of Christ such as, “I and my father are one”, “I am in my father and my father is in me” and “Kingdom of God is within you” as supportive evidences of their theory by claiming that Christ was a person who had this “self realization” and by “I” he meant the realization of the universal consciousness and by saying that “I and my father are one” he meant this non duality.

Advaita seems to be true and looks great on paper as it offers us the unique opportunity to become Gods or realize that we are essentially God himself but the fact is that this non dual being referred to as consciousness doesn’t have an active role/ involvement in everything that happens in the universe or in the life of an individual. Since Advaita believes that this non dual element alone is the reality and everything else is just an illusion all actions of mankind whether good or bad become an illusion and do not have any eternal significance. If we follow this belief, very soon we shall lose the purpose of our existence and life shall become pointless and meaningless, the whole mankind shall become lazy for there is no purpose left for its existence. A series of questions would follow, “If you say that your life is just an illusion then why do you work, live or do good deeds? If these deeds don’t have any eternal significance then what’s the point in living good lives? If both good and evil are illusions then why do good?”

Besides, the key point is that Faith in Advaita means that a seeker should somehow by his own effort remove all the hindrances to self realization (through bhakti, meditation, knowledge or nishkama karma) in order to realize that his essential nature is this non-dual consciousness. Though advaita offers a solution to the lack of peace it does not really bring peace. To realize that all that was there was an illusion and the only thing that really ever existed (from the beginning) was ‘The Self’ ends up as an eternal quest, there is no assurance whether you will reach that state and if at all you reach it, when? You may have to take little less than infinite rebirths to accomplish the goal.

The reason why the proponents of Advaita rule out the possibility of a creator is, according to them the creator would become imperfect if he needs a creation to reflect His glory....but the point is that the creator has created everything not because he needs something else in order to become perfect but because he wills [the faculty of conscious and deliberate choice of action] to create something. Advaita also questions the omnipresence of a creator who has a separate existence from the creation. But the fact is that the creator being a spirit can still remain omnipresent because his spiritual nature allows him to pervade the whole creation just like air pervades everything under the sky. The Bible says that nothing is hidden from him because he pervades the whole creation. Besides, the Bible doesn’t project a creator who is outside of the creation. Instead it proposes a creation that is created for, by and within the creator. For from him and through him and to him are all things. To him be the glory forever! Amen (Romans 11: 36). For by him all things were created: things in heaven and on earth, visible and invisible, whether thrones or powers or rulers or authorities; all things were created by him and for him (Colossians 1: 16).

Now, the question we should ask is which belief is more logical, comprehensive and meaningful? The belief in an omnipresent, omnipotent, omniscient creator who purposefully designs, maintains and finally absorbs the whole creation within himself and gives purpose and meaning to everything seen and unseen or the belief in a non-dual, simple, self–existent consciousness that pervades everything and yet has nothing to do with anything, which neither creates nor destroys, which doesn’t influence anything seen or unseen and is least concerned about the condition of mankind in general, let alone the life of an individual. Another question we should ask ourselves is what is easier for us to do, unite with this so-called universal consciousness by our own endeavor or God to choose us to unite with him spiritually by sending His Spirit to abide in us?

From the above discussion it would be clear that faith in a creator who is personally interested in an individual’s life on earth sounds more sensible and acceptable than the faith in a certain consciousness whose existence cannot be proven as it does not influence nor is influenced by anything seen or unseen. The Holy Bible leads us to such a faith in a creator who loves his creation [man-kind] unconditionally and wants them to unite with him and become like him. In order to do that he humbles himself and incarnates as a man named –Jesus [the savior]. He makes atonement for the sins of mankind on a cross, resurrects the third day and ascends to heaven with a promise that he would return to collect those who believe in him, at the end of days. Then He sends a counselor, the Holy Spirit, who works in the life of the believers to help them attain perfection and finally presents them to the creator at the end of the age to live with Him and in Him forever. Faith in Advaita means that a seeker should somehow, by his own effort remove all the hindrances (through bhakti, meditation, knowledge or nishkama karma) in order to attain perfection but the Christian faith presents a creator who willingly sacrifices his own life to redeem human beings from their sins and reunites with them by sending His own spirit in to them in order to make them perfect, all by His grace and grace alone.                        
                                               
Many of us think that faith in a creator is unscientific. However, recent scientific discoveries justify faith in a creator who is an intelligent designer as being logically more accurate than faith in a consciousness which does not influence nor is influenced by anything seen or unseen. As we discussed in the last chapter, according to modern science all matter, energy, time and space came into existence as a result of the Big-bang. Is it scientifically possible to prove that nothing exploded under nobody's direction at no point in time and everything came into existence? Naturally, anyone who thinks sensibly would ask, “Who initiated the Big-bang?”

No one knows what/who could have triggered the Big-bang. And, scientifically it is impossible to discover this because the laws of physics can no longer guide the Big-bang explosion. The scientists appear to be saying, "We don't know what caused the Big -bang, and the question itself may not make sense.  We'll keep working on it.” Some Atheists say that, “There is still no proof of any deities that may have triggered the Big-bang explosion. You might as well try and say a giant Cyborg bunny triggered the Big-bang.  There is no proof.” As a matter of fact science has not progressed enough to prove the existence of the One who triggered the Big-bang. However, the one who triggered the Big-bang has left some clues in the universe to help us find Him. Let us examine those clues.

The Big-bang theory also suggests that the universe expanded to its current form from a basic subatomic singularity. Studies on the rate of this expansion suggest that if the universe had expanded a little faster, the matter would have sprayed out into space like fine mist from a spray bottle - so fast that a gazillion particles of dust would have sped into infinity and never even form a single star. If the universe had expanded just a little slower, the material would have dribbled out like big drops of water then collapsed back where it came from by the force of gravity. A little too fast, and you get a meaningless spray of fine dust. A little too slow, and the whole universe collapses back into one big black hole. The surprising thing is just how narrow the difference is.  To strike the perfect balance between too fast and too slow, the force, something that physicists call "the Dark Energy Term" had to be accurate to one part in ten with 120 zeros.

In their paper "Disturbing Implications of a Cosmological Constant" two atheist scientists from Stanford University stated that the existence of this dark energy term would essentially require a miracle … "An unknown agent" intervened in cosmic history "for reasons of its own." Just for comparison, the best human engineering example is the Gravity Wave Telescope, which was built with a precision of 23 zeros.  The Designer, the 'external agent' that caused our universe must possess an intellect, knowledge, creativity and power trillions and trillions of times greater than we humans have. Absolutely amazing! Another amazing discovery of scientists, in recent decades, is that many properties of the universe are "just right" for life. Most scientists are convinced that constraints on a life-allowing universe are very tight, that small changes would make the existence of intelligent life impossible. Based on scientific evidence, there is little doubt about this conclusion. There are two main theories for why our universe is "just right" for life, the Intelligent Design theory and the Multiverse theory.

Intelligent design means our universe was designed and created by an extremely intelligent and powerful designer who wanted to create a magnificent world with sunshine, proteins, and people. Whereas, the Multiverse theory suggests that, “Since the probability of a life-supporting universe is extremely low, scientists think that if there are many universes (in a Multiverse) with properties varying throughout the entire range of possibilities, at least one universe may show the properties to support intelligent life.” Basically, Multiverse theory is a way to beat the odds, and it can be used to "explain away" all the evidence for design, whether this evidence occurs at the level of the universe, origin of life, or development of life, or you winning ten consecutive lotteries, because everything will happen if there are enough universes.

Most scientists are convinced that constraints on a life-allowing universe are very tight, that small changes would make the existence of intelligent life impossible. Based on scientific evidence, there is little doubt that many properties of the universe are "just right" for life. Isn’t this data sufficient to prove that the one who triggered the Big-bang is an intelligent designer?  Scientists have enough evidence to prove that everything that exists today has a beginning. They also have sufficient data to suggest that everything has come out of nothing and has been designed intelligently. So isn’t it scientifically reasonable to believe that in the beginning an intelligent designer designed everything to perfection after creating it out of nothing?

Now the question that is left before us is, “Who could that intelligent designer be?” The Hindus and the other religions that have evolved out of Hinduism believe in Advaita, a highly impersonal consciousness that pervades everything and yet has nothing to do with anything, which neither creates nor destroys, which doesn’t influence anything seen or unseen and is least concerned about the condition of mankind in general, let alone the life of an individual. Advaita doesn't advocate an intelligent designer but from the way we find the universe we can see that the Being who has worked behind it has intelligently designed everything to perfection after creating it out of nothing. Therefore, the so called universal consciousness that the proponents of Advaita claim cannot be the one who has triggered the Big-bang.

The only popular religions that believe an intelligent designer as creator God are Judaism, Christianity and Islam. In my opinion, we should compare the lives and/or teachings of the so-called Gods from the books written by the people who claim to be their devotees in order to arrive at a conclusion in this matter; e.g. the Life and teachings of Christ from the Bible and teachings of Allah from the Qur'an. Since we all know that our conscience by which we would be able to know and acknowledge God was also created by Him, we should try to figure out for ourselves the one who represents God’s true nature based on what is acceptable to our conscience.

While most of the religions present a God who hates sinners and then destroys them, The Holy Bible presents a God who is so full of love that not only does he love the repentant sinners but also is willing to die for their cause. The intelligent designer who has designed the Universe to perfection has left one great clue about His nature in the conscience (which again is designed by Him) of mankind. We all by instinct know that sacrificing ones’ life is a greater virtue than killing/destroying others. The one who has triggered the Big-bang and has also designed our conscience to help us know him should be a God of love rather than hatred. God is Love and Jesus Christ is the ultimate expression of God's Love for man-kind. The Bible says, "For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life” (John 3: 16). This proves the God of the Bible is the intelligent designer or creator who has triggered the formation of the universe. So we should conclude that God is not a universal consciousness, but a creator who loves the creation.


Written by: Dr. Manoj Kumar Khatore
From: God In Us A Progressive Revelation
Copyright © 2012 Dr. Manoj Kumar Khatore

No comments:

Post a Comment